Critiques and Feedback Guidelines

Writers:
This club is ONLY for critics to place their advertisement. Please do not post requests. Contact the critics on their thread to request a critique.


Critics:
Create a discussion to advertise your services.

Wattpad is a positive community, Keep it positive
Help authors choose you by letting them know what you love to critique instead of what you won’t critique, feel free to include information about yourself.




Rules
  • Critics have the right to refuse any request without having to provide a reason.

  • Comment Spam posts and Read for Read posts that are only meant to get reads and comments and does not provide writers with real information or feedback about their book is not allowed.

  • Please Specify the payment required for your service, or note if critiques are free. Votes are not allowed as “payments” so please do not mention votes/stars/likes in your advertisement. Monetary payment and any off-Wattpad payment (eg. a follow on other site) are also not allowed in the forums.

  • If you have have decided to temporarily close your thread or have filled up the spots in your thread- please edit your title to say closed to people don’t continue to contact you.

  • If you’d like to have your thread permanently closed, Please tag a community ambassador. An updated list is listed here, Another way to get your thread closed is by adding the tag plsclose and changing your title to 'Permanently close me.

  • Due to the large volume of Critique threads- Threads in this category are closed and sunk, 14 days after the initial creation. You’re still able to edit your posts and get the code from them after they are closed and will always be able to access them via link and your profile.

1 Like
Critique for Critique!
Need a Beta Reader?
CRITIQUE OF THE FIRST 3 CHAPTERS OF YOUR BOOK!
I’ll read your story and give you feedback
I'll Read Your Story Just Cause
𝗞𝗔𝗠'𝗦 𝗨𝗟𝗧𝗜𝗠𝗔𝗧𝗘 𝗥𝗘𝗩𝗜𝗘𝗪 𝗕𝗢𝗢𝗞 (STORY FEEDBACK)
Critiquing ALL Your Stories! (STILL OPEN)
Honest Review
want honest feedback?
Read for read? 😁 (open)
comment for comment (genuine comments!) AND read for read!
Read and Feedback Mystery, Horror, Fantasy
Read and feedback for read and feedback
Started a new story? let's help each other.
First chapter CRITIQUES AND FEEDBACK FOR YOUR BOOK // CLOSED
Read for Read/Feedback
Reading Your Stories (OPEN)
Read for reads!
I will give feedback on your fantasy books
Reviewing the first 3 chapters
FEED BACK FOR YOUR BOOKS [CLOSED]
READ FOR READ - Meaningful critiques
CLOSED
Offering critiques/editing :)
Come here to get reads and comments!!
Read-for-Read Encouragement
Who’s up for a read for read today?
Free Critique & Feedback on Your First Chapter! (Any Genre!)
Read for Read!!!
I Want to Read Your Story
read for read =)
I'll read your book!
Free Feedback on Your First Chapter
CLOSED
Tasty Book Review 1.8 ☕ (CLOSED)
:alien: Alien Critiques :alien: (OPEN)
Read For Read IMMEDIATE RESPONSE!
Read for reads
:star2: Dina Reviews! :star2: CLOSED :white_check_mark: ALL GENRES WELCOMED :heart:
READ & CRITIQUE **ALL** GAY (MXM) WEREWOLF STORIES
:poetry: Feedback for Feedback (Poetry) :hearts:
Review and Trades.
Poetry Read For Reads
Free Reads + Feedback [open closed ✓]
Ya'll want feedback????
Genuine Read for Read!!
Read for Read for any New Stories/Underrated
Honest In-Depth Story Critiques
Critiques & Read for Read on LATER chapters
I’ll read your story, and give you feedback and critiques!
Feedback and friendly critiques for new wattpad writers
Ondrou's Story Critique & Feedback Engine
You can be a reviewer and get your own payment! STILL OPEN
Two Glasses Deep (Open)
Read for Read (3 chapters)
read for read with feedback and inlines! [closed for catchup]
2 chapters Critiques OPEN
KAINEEH CRITIQUES: A CHAPTER FOR A CHAPTER
Read for Read with detailed feedback! [Not taking more stories atm!]
Read for Read (With feedback that is actually helpful)
Critique for critique I don’t bite
Honest, Friendly Feedback ✨ CLOSED ✨
R4R Feedback and review (Rating if wanted.) Closed
Book Exchange (R4R)
Critique for free - Closed for now
CLOSED Honest and Constructive Feedback or Editing :)
Tasty Book Review 1.2 ☕(closed)
CLOSED Read for Read Service :)
Read for Read + complimentary feedback
Offering Critiques Thread 1.2 (Closed moving forward)
SERVICE OFFERED No Strings Critique
Critiques and editing by C.L. Smith. Closed for catch up.
Epic Fantasy Ideas
YA Romance Reads for Reads!
Read-for-Read :)
Long term Read for read. First chapter free (CLOSED)
Read for read of later chapters.
How I feel at your work? (Closed but I be reading the last two books in cue after rest)
Free Feedback! (Closed)
Read for read
LGBT Read For Read
Read for read (first 2 chapters)
READ FOR READ (as many chapters as you read of mine)
Read-for-read with feedback (one chapter)
Reads and Feedbacks on your stories
f l o r a l || c r i t i q u e s || CLOSED FOR CATCH-UP NOT ACCEPTING NEW REQUESTS
Feedback needed. I pay with feedback.
Historical novels, Read for Read
Looking for critique and Feedback
About translation - Is it readable?
Is it readable.... translated to English.
Critique Thread
Any short stories here? Critique for critique (can do novel chapters too)
FEEDBACK WANTED (PAYMENT INCLUDED)
Read for Reads!
Share Your Debut Wattpad Book | Get reads NOW
Read for Read(Closed for catch-up)
READ & CRITIQUE **ALL** GAY WEREWOLF STORIES NO PAYMENT
Classic Critiques (NOW OPEN)
First Chapter Critiques 1.2 (Open)
Read for read
RR: Ruthless Reviews (OPEN)
Feedback & Critiques for YA Novels
Story Services
Everything Goes
Read for read ( Teen fiction or romance)
Read for Read
Reads and Feedbacks on your work 😊
LGBT+ Stories Feedback and Read for Read <CLOSED>
Read For Read
Supernatural Designs | CLOSED
sequiera | closed
LOST & FOUND COVER SHOP
Read for Read?
Offering Minimum of One Chapter Critiques
Feedback From the Average Joe (CLOSED FOR CATCH UP)
Action Scene Critique 2 (OPEN, EMPTY QUEUE)
[ CLOSED] Critiques from someone looking for books to read!
Feedback for Feedback - Short Story or One Chapter :blush:
Read for read + complimentary feedback! open until the thread closes
Reading Romance books and giving feedback.
Simply Being Loved Romance Critques
First Chapter or Short Story Feedback!
Read for Read.
Read and Critique [Closed]
Story Reviews & Critiques *Open Again*
Hey, you up? Read for Reads.
Services
Feedback for feedback: Dystopian/thriller/psychological/comedy
Read for Read
Marvel FanFic Read for Read.
OPEN Read 4 read (chapter for a chapter)
Read and Review First Chapter [CLOSED]
Review/Critique of 1 Chapter [ Closed ]
Poetry Read for Read
Reading with Feedback: FREE (Closed for now)
Reading Critiques!
Radical Reviews, Critiques and Comments (Full for now!)
Read for read
You ask, I read [OPEN]
Feedback on one of your stories! In comments or PM (Your choice)
Read Mine and I'll Read Yours
FINN's Feedback!
Erotica & Romance Critiques by me
Reading and Reviews
I Will Try One Chapter for Free (Closed)
(R4R) Vampire & Werewolf Stories Only
Editing and Chapter Critiques (PAUSED FOR CATCH UP)
Will read and give feedback on your first chapter!
STORY REVIEWS IN YOUR PMs [Closed]
Review for Review - Seeking up to 4 people/ Closed
still life || free reviews || closed
Critiques and Feedback on story of your choice
Chelsea's Critiques
Captain America Critiques ~ OPEN
Read For Read// The Review Machine
First Chapter Feedback for Feedback -- Great for New Users just starting to post
♥ CRITIQUES OFFERED [CLOSED] ♥
I'll give ya some feedback [CLOSED, FERME, CERRADO]
Story review offered! *free*
LaVieEstBelle Book Services (Read for Read & Feedback) || OPEN
Read for Read ヽ(^◇^*)/ FIRST 30 (OPEN)
Read for read
Read for Read and Free Feedback! All Genres [on pause]
SamAndShy Critiquing Service (Closed)
f l o r a l || c r i t i q u e s || CLOSED FOR CATCH-UP NOT ACCEPTING NEW REQUESTS
* will critique your story *read for read *will provide feedback
Honest (Read “Harsh” ) criticism *OPEN*
Book Critiques
Blurb Workshop
A Bitch's Honest Review and Offer for Friendship[CLOSED FOR CATCH UP]
Feedback for feedback -- Science Fiction & Fantasy
Honest (Read “Harsh” ) criticism *OPEN*
Critique for critique (genuine feedback from me)
Read for Read
Detailed Feedback, Quick Payment!
Honest Reviews (CLOSED)
Read for Read (as many chapters as you read of mine)
NOODLE CAT CRITIQUE SERVICE
Feedback offered (⌒o⌒)v♪ \( ̄▽ ̄)/
First Chapter Critiques! (Open)
Can someone be my beta writer
Co-writer Wanted!!:)
Judges Needed for Fun Writing Group
Co-writer wanted! - open
Floral Services || February Contest Open!!
language creator [open!!]
Looking for a writing buddy
Hot Hook Awards [A Unique Writing Contest]
Writing Buddy Wanted For The Great Japanese Detective
I want a writing buddy!
Writing Buddy to Help Push Over the Edge
Looking for Multiple Writing Buddy (Open and Preferably 18+)
Looking for Buddies
Looking for Co-Writer
Wanna be my writing buddy ?
Writing About Type 1 Diabetes (I can help!)
Looking for a writing buddy!
Idea Transfiguration Wizard
Looking to be a co writer
COWRITER!!
Musical, Anime and MLP fan fiction writing group
Autism Fanfiction Mystery Group
FANTASY WRITING GROUP! [OPEN]
Hiring for a new community
Diabolik Lovers, Sailor moon, Cats and Friends Writing club
Looking For Staff To Create A Writing Group (Closed Waiting on a Reply though)
The Great Japanese Detective Writing Group
#FinishYourNovel [MARCH | only cowards will not join]
Writing Group On Amira's Life
Writers Club (Are you struggling to finish you book)
service offered- literary magazine school project
Vampire & Autistic Writers Group
I'll critique your work (2 chapters free)
Critique for critique: CFCU
Read for Read!! Come in
Feeling Like Some Poems
Read for read! Let's swap stories! (CLOSED)
I'll critique your work!
:desert: Sahara v.2 || First Chapter Reviews || [OPEN!]
Offering CONSTRUCTIVE Critiques! [[CLOSED]]
I Will Read Your Story! (Read for Read)
Science fiction/dystopian read for read closed
Read For Read
Critiques; By June
Ben's Best Advice
Surface-level feedback or deep critique. Your choice.
Hey, you up? Read for Reads.
When will Wattpad moderators control homophobia and racism in forum posts?
Read for Read! (Feedback) CLOSED
Action Scene Critique (CFCU)
Allie's Critiques and Review Service (Open)
Ravi's Critiques! [closed :')]
Shakespearean Critiques (All Genres Accepted)
Read for Read (open)
Open to read new stories since I'm trying to get back to Wattpad and chilling for the moment
Feedback/Read for Feedback/Read
READ FOR READ
High Quality Critiques (CLOSED)
I will rate your romance Story [OPEN]
Feedback for Feedback [OPEN]
Ill critique your poetry, and offer advice!
Read for Feedback!
Poetry Readings
Destiny Island Critiques!💫🌴 (CLOSED)
Karan Seraph Critiques (open)
Roxy Pop's Critique Shop {c l o s e d}
looking for help with new story
COMMENT OR FEEDBACK FOR YOUR STORY
Filipino Writers Read for Read
HONEST READ FOR READ! (English | Filipino)
Read/comment for read/comment
Belle Critiques! (Open)
Hello :)
Reviewing Your First Chapter!! (closed)
Read for read. (CURRENTLY CLOSED)
cιяcε cяιтιqυεs | ғεε∂вαcк & яεvιεω | open
Read for Read!
Jack-of-all-trades Read for Read. Let's give this another shot 👍😉
HONEST FEEDBACK (open)
Honest Feedback & Read | OPEN TO NEW POSTS
Read for Read (as many as you read of mine)
Three Chapters, Three Comments Deal :) [OPEN]
feedback and read for read
{DYSTOPIAN/ADVENTURE} Beta Readers Needed (Payment Offered)
(I've taken this one down)
TRANSLATION OF A STORY (HP fandom)
Free story advice & help
ROMANCE NOVELS REVIEWS
Free story advice & help
The Salt Factory
Read for read( max 15 chapters!)
~Fast REVIEWS and CRITIQUES~ FULL STORY {CLOSED}
I'll read the first chapter of your book
Beta Readers for a Chicklit story.
Looking For Beta Readers! (For Mature) (Open)
feedback and read for read 1.3 [CLOSED FOR CATCH UP]