In 1988, Kimmy Cooper was violently murdered at Fairweather Lake during a party, her boyfriend was found standing over her, broken beer bottle in hand and blood splattered across his clothes. With the case still unsolved and cold thanks to the negligence of the police almost thirty years later people have come to their own conclusions about what happened that night.
Marlowe Bishop has never paid too much attention to the rumors of what happened that night. She had a tendency to avoid gossip, and instead always kept her head stuck in her books. At least they had endings.
It isn’t until Kennedy Carmichael, Marlowe’s new friend is murdered exactly thirty years after Kimmy’s murder in the same exact situation, only with Marlowe’s boyfriend found above her this time, that Marlowe really starts to pay attention to the case.
Marlowe, along with her three friends start to piece together every piece of information they have surrounding both murders, but with all four of them being the prime suspects for Kennedy’s murder, can they trust anyone? Even themselves?