Need help categorizing novel

Hey, I need help categorizing my latest novel I’ve been writing and now working on revising drafts, which I’m planning later down the road to query to agents. The story is told through a twelve year old protagonist and throughout most of it he is that age until at the end he is almost in his thirties. I wanted it to be a coming of age for adults since the genre is horror and it has scary, a bit gory, and explicit content, does this sound like a coming of age novel for an adult audience?

Any thoughts and help would be great, thanks :):slightly_smiling_face:

If the genre is horror then I’d suggest categorizing it as such.

Though not necessarily limited to such stories, Coming of Age tales tend hold the connotation of upbeat, inspirational, and have an air of self-improvement to them. As a reader, if I picked up a story marketed as Coming of Age and realized I was holding a horror story, I’d be pretty upset.
Just ask yourself what’s the driving force? Is it the suspense and tension, or is it the learning that the main character endures?

1 Like

Okay, thanks for advice! And I’d say it has a bit of both.

1 Like

Cool! Well I’d say all books combine multiple elements from multiple genres, what your job is, it to find the underlying theme that is present throughout the book.

Take care, and good luck :slight_smile:

1 Like

What audience is this written for? Do you want adult readers to read it (i.e. over 25). Or is it Young adult (roughly 18-22)? The audience, together with your genre, defines the classification of your novel

1 Like

It’s probably YA Horror. It might be adult Horror.

I’d say the audience could be both young adult and adult, which makes it harder for me to define it.

For the purposes of traditional publishing, pick one. I’d recommend starting with YA. Query all the agents who rep that genre. Don’t tell them it could be either/or – let them decide that. If you get no interest from those agent, then revise your query to say adult Horror, and then query all the agents who rep that.

If you self publish, you have to identify your target audience. If you’re querying, you can take your best shot at a genre and let the agent make the final determination.

1 Like

Alright, thanks for the advice! I’ll have this in mind when I’m ready to query this project.

1 Like

Here I will dare to respectfully disagree with the wonderful and published XimeraGrey, whose opinions on publishing issues I’ve come to respect. I only dare because I had the opportunity to discuss topics like this with some trad-published YA authors.

To summarize, trad is very sensitive to classification factors such as protagonist age when it comes to certain categories, most especially YA. One published YA author put it simply: for a debut YA, your protag has to be 16, and that’s it. Another said 15 and 17 are possible (she was being nice, because my protag happened to be 14), but agents and publishers are looking for 16. I found quite a bit of corroborating evidence in agent blogs. I’ve since aged my protag to 15 :slight_smile:

The readership age bracket for the trad “YA” category is 13-18 year olds (not 18-22 as another poster suggested; technically 18-22 is ‘New Adult’, but that’s a whole different kettle of soft porn … I mean fish). Like pre-teens, younger YA readers like to ‘read up’. They want to read about how characters deal with issues they already sense they’ll face with when they reach that age - if not before. This ‘read up’ effect peters out around age 17, because by then, they know it all, right? Would a 15 year-old want to read about a 12 year-old? Generally not.

YA is also about tone and theme and topic. YA is self-focussed (some would say self-obsessed), relationship-oriented, personal and social issues-exploring, etc. All these coming-of-age things. For a twelve year-old protag to be that inward-looking would probably read as unnatural. To a YA reader, the outward-focussed, drier tone of a natural child protagonist tends to be less interesting.

So if you’re trying the traditional route, I think you got it right with “I wanted it to be a coming of age for adults since the genre is horror and it has scary, a bit gory, and explicit content,” It sounds like something a publisher would classify as Adult. Note: Adult us much less sensitive to protag age - pretty much anything goes. It’s all about the story.

Finally, if you’re submitting to agents, they like to see that you know what shelving category your book should end up in. If you call something that reads like an Adult novel a “YA” novel, they might ditch your query simply because it looks like you haven’t done your research. They’re all about the business: they want to know that your work follows the rules and can sell.

Are there exceptions? Sure. For example, The Knife of Never Letting Go by Patrick Ness. The MC is12, but the book is AR-classified as Upper Grade, typically shelved as YA. Ness was successfully published before he wrote it, so he had latitude. Harry Potters were exceptions - everyone read HP from age 11 to whatever he was at the end. Statistically, though, you’re not that likely to be one of the exceptions.

That’s traditional publishing.

If it’s self-pub, you have much more freedom - but at least you still have to know your target audience in order to package and market to them.


Nothing you’ve said makes me think it’s anything other than adult horror. Your MC is too young for YA or NA anyway.

1 Like